Skip to main content

Review - THE SECRET GOSPEL OF IRELAND by James Behan and Leo Behan

One of the things which some people here in India love to tell me is that: 'your Christianity is only two thousand years old, while our Hinduism is over five thousand years old'.  As if Hinduism, being more ancient, somehow has more legitimacy than the Christian faith.  So the first thing I always say when I hear something like that is that the roots of Christianity reach further back than two thousand years until the beginnings of mankind.  The Old Testament which traces the history of mankind's fall and God's gathering of the Children of Israel to be His people goes back into the mists of time and if age validates religion, then the Judaeo-Christian faith would not be found wanting.  However, I'm not in competition with anyone to prove 'my' faith is better than theirs.  I've heard the message of Jesus Christ and I believe in it.  Amen.

The life and sacrifice of Jesus Christ was the culmination of God's promises to his Chosen People throughout Old Testament times.  When the Saviour was born and made the ultimate Sacrifice, all the promises of the Old Testament were fulfilled.  The first followers of Christ ('Christians' as they became known) were in fact members of the Israelite (Jewish) community.  But that community, as a whole, did not accept Jesus as the promised Messiah (Saviour) even though there are Jewish followers of Jesus today, known as Messianic Jews. The early Christians, being Jewish or Greek converts to Judaism, simply explained the Christian message in terms of the Jewish/Israelite vision, that man disobeyed God and fell from grace.  God made a Covenant with Israel and promised to send a Saviour.  They accepted that message and were absorbed into the early Church, which is the collective term for Christians.  Eventually, Christianity spread its influence and after time,  became the official religion of the Roman Empire.  There were many new followers to the faith but most of these would not understand the Christian message in Jewish terms.  As the message of Christ spread, people, through ignorance of the Scriptures, didn't even properly comprehend the faith, nor what it really meant.  Christianity became just another religion with rules and regulations.  Astonishing, considering the fact that Jesus Christ Himself detested religion with it's trappings of rules, regulations and hypocrisy.  The Word of God was falling on thin soil indeed.    Not to mention the fact that Eastern Christianity and Western Christianity separated from each other.

This book THE SECRET GOSPEL OF IRELAND, traces the history of the Christian faith from its obscure beginnings.  In clear, layman's language, it shows us how an African man named Augustine went from being what Christians would have considered as a sinner to  one of the greatest saints of his time.  He shows us how Augustinian thought shaped Christian theology. I'm afraid I'm not overly impressed by Augustine nor his mother Monica.  My local priest often pointed out my similarity with Monica in the sense that I'm married to a man of another faith and mentioned that thanks to Monica's prayers her husband and son ultimately adopted  Christianity.  I'm appalled by Monica's handling of Augustine's life.  Augustine had a concubine, an African woman who bore him a son.  That woman followed him faithfully from Africa to Italy.  Yet Monica cruelly dismissed her from Augustine's life.  Augustine, who was of quite a mature age, sadly bade his concubine goodbye, keeping their son with him and agreed to marry a young girl his mother had chosen, who was yet not old enough to marry.  I find St. Monica's behaviour most inhuman and unChristian.  Ultimately, Augutine didn't marry the young lady, choosing to become a priest instead.  As the body of  theological knowledge grew, the Christian faith spread to beyond the borders of the Roman Empire.  That's where Ireland comes in.

When St. Patrick brought Christianity to the remote island of  Ireland, Ireland adopted a great monastic tradition, which had actually spread that far from the Egyptian desert.  The Irish monasteries were universities of knowledge and the Irish took to Christianity and learning like ducks take to water.  Ireland's location on the remote outskirts of Europe may have cut it off from mainland Europe, but their Christianity, their knowledge of Augustine's theology and their Latin was infinitely superior even to that of Rome.  In time Irish missionaries were going out to Europe, spreading Christianity throughout the continent.  Apparently, one of the great contributions of Irih monks  to Christianity was their emphasis on penance and good works to bring one closer to God.  The Irish stood out among European Christians because their tonsure was distinctive and different.  Also, they celebrated Easter at different times, which was later brought into line with that of the Roman Church.

This book is basically a short history of Christianity, from its inception to the present day, with special emphasis on the role the Irish monks played in the Church as a whole.  The language is accessible and iteh book reads like a rather interesting article - you don't feel you're reading a book at all.  One of the things I found slightly irritating was that it kept on referring to the Church  in pre-Reformation days as 'the Roman Catholic Church', which it wasn't, well not yet anyway. It tells us of St. Thomas Aquinas and Erasmus and their role in shaping Catholic thought.  It gives a clear account of how Martin Luther began a crusade against the abuses of the system of selling indulgences and ended up leading the Reformation in western Christianity.  This story doesn't have a lot to do with Ireland, but it makes enjoyable reading.  Ireland has always had a symbiotic relationship with the Romanc Catholic Church, a relationship which has, incidentally, shaped our national identity in many ways, although that statement may not please the minority community of Irish Protestants.  Ireland is currently trying to escape it's Catholic identity, it seems.  The words 'Ireland is a Catholic country' resounded around the world recently and almost convicted us of bigotry and racial discrimination, even though the words were a well meant way to describe why Ireland in general has always followed the pro-life ethos.

People interested in Irish history, lay people and students alike, as well as people interested in reading about Church history, would find this book fascinating.  As the authors declare in their summing up: 

It started as a vision of heaven, infinite and eternal, in the mind of an African bishop who didn't know peace until he rested in God.  Soon, however, the Word became flesh as  the monks of Ireland endeavored to imitate Christ in body and mind.  They built monasteries and schools and hospitals.  They cared for the sick, comforted the poor, and educated countless generations.  They did penance and followed Christ from earth to heaven, bringing forth an esthetic transformation of the Western mind that changed the world.  They built a civilization like the sculptor who toils in silence to give voice to a stone.  We wear their legacy like a halo.  And even if many people today don't believe in God or Jesus Christ, we are free because they did.

Somewhere the Irish monks are smiling.


  1. That sounds a very good book with some meaty things in it.
    I also have had people of other faiths tell me that Christianity isn't that old, whereas their faith is. However I love your answer and would say that its mine too.
    Maggie x

    Nuts in May


Post a comment

Thanks for visiting me. Please let me know you were here

Popular posts from this blog


Many years ago, when I lived in Dublin, I met someone nice and started dating. I wasn't serious, I just thought we could have nice interesting discussions about India, which I found absolutely fascinating, as I was working in the Embassy of India back then. I had no intention of getting attached with a foreigner, with all the attendant cultural problems. I was happy living in Ireland and the idea of marriage couldn't have been further from my mind. We both thought we could just keep things in control. One day, after a lot of emotional turmoil and denial, it hit us both that we were in love. Truly. Madly. Irrevocably. To the point where we couldn't live without each other. I'd known about the Indian system of arranged marriages and when it occurred to me that he would probably be married off by his family as soon as he returned to India, I felt physically ill at the thought. We are both tenacious and patient people. We realised that bringing our two worlds together

Kipling Got it Wrong! Or Eastern and Western Culture - Reflections

What Is Culture? I’m opening this blog post with a question. What is that elusive concept which is commonly known as ‘culture? Culture is way of life. How we live. What our values are.  Our customs, attitudes and perceptions. And also, I suppose, how we express ourselves in art through, such as music, dance, theatre and cinema.  It’s quite a comprehensive area and not too easy to define, really. Travel between east and west is common nowadays The Journey I was born in what is commonly known as ‘the west’. I lived in Ireland for the first thirty years of my life. When I was thirty, I married my husband and came out to India to live here with him. That was the beginning of an interesting journey, which is still evolving. I must have had some east/west comparison stereotypes in my head. But in India, I found that the people I met had huge stereotypes in their heads about what they called ‘western culture’ and ‘western way of life’. Not long after

The Tale of One Kitty

The cat..... Those who know me already might say that they didn't know I had a cat.  I didn't, you know! Our dog, Duggu is such a handful, I didn't think we could take on another pet. But a few months ago, a beautiful cat (whom we eventually named Puggle)  arrived. She's not really ours..... Nope! She's someone else's cat who just went on what the Aussies might call a walkabout. My younger daughter Riya found her on the roof of our house, a pretty calico (three-coloured) cat. Riya was instantly smitten. Some milk was fed to the little creature and the deal was sealed. Puggle has been a regular visitor to our house ever since. And two days after she arrived, in mid-May, she gave birth to four kittens. We'd had no idea the kitty was enceinte. So what did we do? What can you do? If a single mom landed on your doorstep and gave birth in your house, what would you do? Try to help, obviously. As the cat bore no identification and had been roaming the colony unst